Suicides in the military soar as the wars drag on

Military brass are part of the problem not the solution

August 9, 2010
By Bill Hackwell

The writer is a Vietnam veteran and member of March Forward!

New statistics show the rate of suicides in the military continues to soar, with June breaking a record for the largest number of self-inflicted deaths in U.S. military history. There were 21 active duty and 11 reserve soldier suicides in June, including seven in Iraq and Afghanistan. Suicide rates in the military for the first half of the year are up 20 percent over 2009. According to TheHill.com, “Based on the most recent data, more than 34,500 people died from suicide in the U.S. in 2007.” Approximately one-in-five of those are veterans. A CBS News study in that same year polled suicide rates in 45 states and discovered that a national average of 125 veterans take their lives every week.

These suicide figures correspond with dramatic increases in military discharges for mental disorders directly related to the wars. In a recent article in USA Today, it was revealed that Army records show a 64 percent increase in discharges due to mental illness from post traumatic stress disorder or traumatic brain injury since 2005. “In more than 120 studies done on the issue of completed suicide, 90% of the individuals were suffering from mental illness at the time of their death”. (TheHill.com, June 28)

So what has been the Pentagon’s response to the suicide crisis? In March 2009, the Army created the Army Suicide Prevention Task Force. The first thing the task force did was have an Army-wide stand down to basically order everyone not to commit suicide. They showed them a hastily put together prevention movie. The problem was that some of the “soldiers” in the film were actors and the movie was laughed at by real soldiers who complained that it did not reflect the many problems of military life.

Ignoring the recent statistics, at a June meeting between the task force and generals from other branches of the military with the Senate Armed Services Committee, General Peter Chiarelli reported great strides were being made in suicide prevention. All the generals agreed at the hearing that prevention starts with leadership in encouraging soldiers to come forward with mental health problems. The other issue they agreed upon is the importance of family connectedness for individuals suffering from depression and drug and alcohol abuse.

The contradiction that generals face here is that they are the biggest part of the problem and not part of the solution at all. From the very first day of boot camp, a soldier is trained to be tough, to be all you can be, and to suck up pain to carry out a soldier’s mission. Soldiers are brainwashed to think they are superior and braver than their enemy. This basic element of military orientation flies in the face of saying there is no stigma in seeking mental health services, as the generals now claim. Soldiers feel they will be disgraced, not trusted in their units and be turned down for promotion if they seek assistance.

As big as battlefield trauma is in contributing to mental health problems and suicide, multiple tours of duty to Iraq and Afghanistan are also a major factor. According to USA Today, “Army Lt. Col. Rebecca Porter, a behavioral health official, said research shows ‘a clear relationship between multiple deployments and increased symptoms of anxiety, depression and PTSD.’” The “family connectedness” the generals sang about in Congress can never happen with the family separation that comes with multiple deployments. As the occupation of Iraq continues and as casualties grow in Afghanistan, this health crisis will only get worse. The only way it will get better is to end the occupations and to bring the troops home now.


Related stories

Shinseki Resignation: Political Blame Game Misses the Real Scandal

A March Forward! statement on the resignation of Gen. Shinseki from the VA Read more.
Issue: Veterans
 

"To my fellow sailors: Refuse your orders to attack Syria!"

As U.S. warships position themselves in the Mediterranean Sea, preparing to strike Syria, a young Navy veteran sends a message to fellow sailors. Read more.
Issue: Veterans
 

VIDEO: Iraq war veteran on the real reasons the U.S. is attacking Syria

March Forward! co-founder and Iraq war veteran Mike Prysner discusses the lies around the Syria war on The Young Turks network. Read more.
Issue: Veterans